Jim Wilke jwilke123 at comcast.net
Sat Apr 5 18:12:18 EDT 2008

I always thought if you upped the tempo to a medium bounce (musical 
term: "business man's bounce") and imagine Bix playing it on cornet 
with Hoagy's swingy staccato piano at an Ivy League dance in the 20s, 
you'd have a good impression of the tune's original sound - different 
from the latter day legato ballad style associated with Billy 
Butterfield and the Artie Shaw hit recording.   I don't really hear it 
in "Singin' the Blues" except for a couple of brief phrases, but the 
tempo and phrasing are appropriate, and most musicians are influenced 
by those they play with.

Anyone know of a recording of the tune by Bix and Hoagy?   Sudhalter?  
Applebaum?  allmusic.com lists 1935 recordings of the tune Stardust 
(one word) and my connection times out before it can load them all.

Jim Wilke

On Saturday, April 5, 2008, at 10:37  AM, Jazz Promo Services wrote:

> The song's dirty little secret is that it is essentially a rip off of
> Bix's famous solo in "Singin' the Blues", which makes sense, since Bix
> and Hoagy hung out together. George Harris AAJLA
>> Jon Hendricks says that one of the Harlem stride pianists (Lucky
>> Roberts?) wrote "Stardust" and sold it to Carmichael. Hendricks has
>> mentioned this in public, I believe, and as it is I've heard this
>> story second hand from a student who was in a class where Hendricks
>> asserted this I have little faith in it. Someone should ask Hendricks
>> about this on the record before he's gone.
>> Lazaro Vega
>> Blue Lake Public Radio
> --

More information about the jazzproglist mailing list